My new and old favorite store: Schmancy. Where else in the city can you get collectible toys shaped like different kinds of milk? And plush doughnuts? And crochet deviled eggs? In the same place? I'm guessing nowhere else. Go to Schmancy - 2nd Ave between Stewart and Virginia. And while you're there, visit Nancy, Fancy and Pants. They don't have collectible milk toys, but they are also awesome.